19 11 月, 2026
撰写的 WID.world

The hidden Great Levelling that standard inequality measures miss

Have two centuries of economic and institutional change made societies more equal? By standard measures, the answer is no. Across the 48 countries with long-run data, the richest 1%’s share of national income averaged 18% in 1820. It is 18% today. Read at face value, these figures suggest organised labour, democratisation and decolonisation left elite control over resources unchanged.

In this paper, Andrés Irarrázaval documents a global Great Levelling, invisible in standard top income shares. In poorer times, much of national income was tied to subsistence. Transferring this income to the top 1% would have left the other 99% below what they needed to survive. The paper factors this subsistence constraint into inequality measurement and studies how the surplus, income not tied to subsistence, is distributed within 48 countries over two centuries.

 

KEY FINDINGS

  • The top 1% share of national surplus fell from 53% in 1820 to 40% in 1920 and 19% today, a nearly threefold decline in elite control over transferable resources (Figure 1A).
  • Top income shares hide this decline because they are measured against all national income, including the part needed for subsistence. The paper calls this part the subsistence floor. In 1820, that floor made up 62% of national income. Today it makes up 10% (Figure 1B). The same 18% of national income was therefore a much bigger slice of the surplus then than now.
  • The new surplus went mainly to the other 99%. Growth, by lifting incomes above subsistence, expanded the share of national income that could accrue to the top 1%, from 38% in 1820 to 90% today. Yet top income shares did not rise over the long run.
  • The bottom 50% were the main winners. Their average share of national surplus rose from 1–3% before the Second World War to 13% today.
  • Surplus income gives households the means to pursue goals beyond immediate necessity, such as saving, affording leisure or paying for a child’s education. That capacity underpins what Amartya Sen (1999) calls “substantive freedoms”, and it is now far more widely shared.
  • The Great Levelling began in the late 19th century, coinciding with the rise of organised labour and mass democracy (Figure 1A). It was steepest during and after the Second World War and partly reversed after 1980.
  • Redistribution played a secondary role. Comparing pre-tax with post-tax surplus shares, the paper finds that taxes and transfers account for only a tenth of the long-run fall in the top 1% surplus share.
  • The evidence points instead to pre-distribution forces that raised workers’ market incomes, such as their rising bargaining power. By the late 19th century, industrialisation had concentrated workers in factories. There they could organise, threaten unrest and press for a wage floor well above bare subsistence.

Figure 1. The top 1% share of national income barely moved over two centuries, while its share of the surplus fell almost threefold (panel A), as growth lifted incomes far above the subsistence floor (panel B).

Notes. The top 1% share of national surplus = (top 1% income share × national income − 1% × subsistence floor) / (national income − subsistence floor). The subsistence floor as a share of national income is the minimum cost of subsistence per capita over national income per capita. The world series is the country average weighted by population. See Irarrázaval, The Hidden Great Levelling, for details.

 

AUTHOR

  • Andrés Irarrázaval, London School of Economics
下载