December 20, 2023
Written by WID.world

To become or not to become French: conscription, naturalization, and labor market integration

Migrant-receiving countries are increasingly tightening regulations governing the acquisition of various forms of residence and work permits. In this context, naturalization, which represents the final legal step in the integration process for migrants, has been a focus of debate. Yet, there is little evidence on how migrants respond to changes in the cost of naturalization, and on the impact of naturalization on their economic integration.

Yajna Govind and Louis Sirugue’s research focuses on France, a country where citizenship is automatically granted to individuals born in France to foreign parents*, and where compulsory military service made naturalization a costly choice in the 1990s.  They use the abolition of compulsory conscription in 1997 for men born after 1978 as an exogenous shock in the costs of acquiring French citizenship for children to study the impact of the reform on the naturalization decisions of second-generation immigrants, and the causal effect of naturalization on labor market outcomes.

 

Key findings:

  • The reform led to an increase in male naturalization rates, driven entirely by European Union citizens. As a result, the employment probability of EU males increased by 2 percentage points, mainly through a reduction in inactivity rather than unemployment.
  • This is mainly driven by an increase in public-sector employment and a reduction in self-employment, and is associated with an enhanced sense of belonging.
  • Policies that affect naturalization costs heterogeneously across immigrants can unintentionally deprive certain groups of improved labor market prospects.

 

AUTHORS

  • Yajna Govind, Copenhagen Business School, World Inequality Lab, CI-Migration
  • Louis Sirugue, Paris School of Economics

 

MEDIA CONTACT

  •  press[at]wid.world

 

*This paper is published in the context of France having just passed a bill on 19 December 2023 that restricts birthright citizenship for people born in France to foreign parents, among other measures.

downloads